Why a 5mg Edible Hits Everyone Differently

Written by Lorien Strydom

November 11th, 2025

You and your friend split the same pack of 5mg gummies from the same batch. An hour later, they're melting into the couch while you're checking your watch, wondering if anything's happening.

Three hours after that, you're finally feeling it while they're already coming down. Sound familiar?

Here's what's actually going on: edibles travel through your digestive system and liver first, where they're converted into a different, more potent compound called 11-hydroxy-THC.

Your liver's conversion speed—primarily determined by genetics—creates wildly different experiences from the identical starting THC amount.

We're breaking down exactly why that 5mg lands so differently, what you can actually control, and how to find your personal sweet spot without the guesswork.

Expect onset anywhere from 30 to 120 minutes, with effects lasting 6 to 12 hours—sometimes with subtle effects into the next day.

Table of Contents

• Why Edibles Feel Different Than Smoking or Vaping

• The Timing Window That Changes Everything

• What Makes the Same THC Amount Land Differently

• How Food and Fat Change the Curve

• Finding Your Personal THC Amount Without the Guesswork

• Why Two 10mg Gummies Can Feel Completely Different

• What to Do If It Feels Like Too Much

• How Regular Use Changes What You Feel

• Hemp-Derived vs Dispensary THC and Other Practical Questions

• Your Next 5mg With Confidence

Why Edibles Feel Different Than Smoking or Vaping

When you smoke or vape cannabis, THC takes the express route: lungs to bloodstream to brain in minutes.

You feel effects almost immediately, they peak quickly, and you're usually back to baseline within a couple of hours.

The difference with edibles is dramatic.

Edibles take the scenic route through your entire digestive system.

First stop is your stomach, where THC begins breaking down, then your intestines, where it gets absorbed, and finally your liver, where the real transformation happens.

Your liver converts regular Delta-9 THC into 11-hydroxy-THC, a compound that crosses into your brain more effectively and creates effects that feel stronger and last considerably longer.

This isn't the same THC you'd experience from smoking—it's a different active compound entirely.

Here's why your smoking tolerance means almost nothing for edibles: you're not building tolerance to the same compound.

A decade of smoking experience doesn't prepare you for how 11-hydroxy-THC affects your system.

Think of it like being an expert wine drinker trying whiskey for the first time—both are alcohol, but your body processes them differently and the experience isn't the same.

The Daily Smoker's Surprise

If you smoke regularly and figure 10mg will be nothing because of your high tolerance, you're in for a surprise. That daily smoking habit built tolerance to inhaled THC, not the liver-converted compound you're about to experience.

Many experienced smokers find edibles hit harder and last longer than expected, even at seemingly modest THC amounts.

Explore our categories

Shop All

Gummies

Flower

Edibles

Beverages

Vapes

Pre-Rolls

Concentrates

Bestsellers

Merch

Shop All

The Timing Window That Changes Everything

Traditional edibles take 30 to 120 minutes to start working, with most people feeling initial effects somewhere in the 45 to 90 minute range.

Effects typically peak around 3 to 4 hours after consumption, then gradually taper over the next several hours.

The total experience usually lasts 6 to 12 hours, with some people reporting subtle effects—like slight grogginess or lingering relaxation—into the next day.

This extended timeline is radically different from smoking's quick rise and fall.

The Classic Mistake That Ruins Experiences

Here's the single biggest error people make: taking more before the first amount kicks in. You eat a gummy at 7pm, feel nothing by 8:30pm, assume it's not working, and eat another one.

What you've actually done is stack two separate waves. When the first gummy finally hits around 9pm, the second one is right behind it. By 10 or 11pm, both reach peak intensity simultaneously, creating effects far more intense than you wanted.

The fix is simple but requires patience: wait the full 2 hours before even considering more.

If you're new to edibles or trying a new product, give it the full window.

Faster Options for Impatient Types

If traditional edible timing drives you crazy, rapid-onset gummies using nano-emulsification technology start working in 5 to 15 minutes.

These formulations create smaller THC particles that your body absorbs more quickly, giving you feedback closer to smoking timelines while maintaining the extended duration edibles are known for.

For a concert starting at 8 pm, traditional edibles should be taken by 6 pm or 6:30 pm to align with the show.

Rapid-onset options let you wait until 7:30pm or 7:45pm for similar timing—useful when you want more control over when effects begin.

What Makes the Same THC Amount Land Differently

Your liver contains enzymes—specifically from the cytochrome P450 family—that process THC into 11-hydroxy-THC.

Genetic variations mean some people's livers are overachievers while others take a more relaxed approach, with enzyme production varying by a factor of 10 or more between individuals.

If your liver genes code for high enzyme production, even small THC amounts produce intense effects because you're efficiently creating lots of the potent compound.

If your liver produces fewer enzymes, you might need significantly higher amounts to feel anything at all.

Fast Metabolizers vs Slow Metabolizers

"Fast metabolizers" have livers that rapidly convert THC, often experiencing quicker onset but shorter overall duration. These folks might feel effects in 30 to 45 minutes but find the experience winds down by hour 6 or 7.

"Slow metabolizers" have more leisurely enzyme production, creating gentler, more gradual experiences that take longer to start but can last the full 10 to 12 hours.

Neither is better—they're just different biological realities that explain why you and your friend have opposite timelines from identical gummies.

Tolerance From Regular Use

If you use cannabis daily—whether smoking, vaping, or eating edibles—your CB1 receptors become less sensitive through a process called downregulation.

Your body essentially says "we're getting a lot of this compound, let's dial down the response."

Daily users often need significantly higher THC amounts than occasional users for comparable effects. That 5mg that overwhelms a newbie might barely register for someone with established tolerance.

Regular users also tend to experience shorter duration—where a naive user gets 10 hours, a daily consumer might get 5 or 6.

The "Ediblocked" Phenomenon

A small percentage of people are what we call "ediblocked" —edibles simply don't work for them, period. They could eat 100mg and feel absolutely nothing while their friend transcends reality from 5mg.

These individuals have a genetic variant that makes their liver enzymes convert THC into inactive compounds instead of 11-hydroxy-THC. If you've tried multiple products at various amounts with zero effects, you're likely in this category.

The solution isn't edibles at all. Sublingual tinctures placed under your tongue bypass liver conversion entirely, with THC absorbing directly through blood vessels in your mouth for effects more similar to smoking.

Some "ediblocked" folks also find success combining edibles with small amounts of vaped cannabis to kickstart effects.

Other Individual Factors

Body composition, hydration status, age, and biological sex all influence how edibles land.

THC is fat-soluble, so body fat percentage affects distribution and storage. Hydration impacts how efficiently your digestive system processes cannabinoids.

Hormonal fluctuations create predictable patterns in edible intensity. Even daily variations in hormone levels from typical life demands can shift how the same amount affects you on different days.

How Food and Fat Change the Curve

THC is fat-soluble, which means it binds to dietary fats in your digestive system. This simple fact dramatically changes how edibles hit you based on what and when you've eaten.

On an empty stomach, THC races through your digestive system and hits your liver fast.

Expect onset in 30 to 45 minutes, but the curve tends to be shorter and sometimes more intense—like a steep hill that drops quickly rather than a gentle slope.

The Fatty Meal Effect

Take that same edible after a meal with healthy fats—avocado toast, peanut butter, a burger, anything with substantial fat content—and everything slows down.

Onset might not happen until 90 to 120 minutes, but the effects unfold more gradually and last longer.

The fat helps your body absorb THC more efficiently while giving your liver more time to process everything at a steady pace. Many experienced users swear by taking edibles with a spoonful of peanut butter or after a meal specifically for this smoother ride.

Finding Your Sweet Spot

Most people find their optimal experience somewhere between completely empty and completely full.

A light snack with some fat content about 30 minutes before or alongside your edible often provides the best balance: reasonable onset time, smooth absorption, and extended duration without overwhelming intensity.

Same person, same 5mg gummy, two entirely different experiences just from meal timing.

Track what you ate and when to identify your personal pattern.

Finding Your Personal THC Amount Without the Guesswork

Here are realistic starting ranges based on experience level and typical tolerance: Beginners should start with 2.5mg to 5mg.

This provides a light, manageable introduction similar to having one drink—enough to feel effects without overwhelming intensity. First-time users need special guidance to find their baseline.

Regular users who consume cannabis weekly usually land in the 10mg to 25mg range.

If you smoke or vape occasionally but aren't building daily tolerance, start around 10mg and adjust from there.

Experienced daily users often need 20mg to 30mg or higher for desired effects.

Some long-term users with significant tolerance require 50mg or more—though amounts above 30mg should only be approached after systematically building up.

The Systematic Mapping Process

Here's how to find your personal sweet spot: Start with 2.5mg even if it seems ridiculously small. Document everything: what you took, exact timing, what you'd eaten that day, and how you felt at the 2-hour, 4-hour, and 6-hour marks.

After a week, try the same amount under different conditions—empty stomach versus with food, morning versus evening. Once you're comfortable with how 2.5mg affects you, increase by 2.5mg increments, waiting at least 2 to 3 days between experiments.

This systematic approach takes a few weeks but gives you reliable data about your personal response pattern. You'll know your onset time, peak intensity, total duration, and how food timing shifts everything.

Why Product Consistency Matters

A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that only 17% of tested edibles were labeled correctly. When you don't know how much THC you're actually consuming, individual variability gets compounded by product inconsistency.

We use high-quality hemp extracts with precise amounts, testing each batch for quality, safety, and consistency. Every product comes with a Certificate of Analysis showing third-party lab results.

This removes the "is this actually 5mg" variable from your personal mapping process.

Why Two 10mg Gummies Can Feel Completely Different

Even when two products contain identical THC amounts, the overall formulation dramatically shapes your experience. Cannabinoid ratios, terpene profiles, and supporting compounds all influence how effects unfold.

A 10mg gummy with added CBD often feels more balanced and less intense than pure THC at the same amount.

Terpenes—aromatic compounds from cannabis—contribute their own subtle effects.

Supporting ingredients like adaptogens or nootropics in targeted formulations can shift the character of the experience.

Traditional vs Rapid-Onset Formulations

 Nano-emulsified products break THC into much smaller particles—sometimes under 30 nanometers compared to hundreds of nanometers in traditional edibles.

These smaller particles absorb faster and often feel stronger per milligram for many people, even though the total THC amount is the same.

If you're switching from traditional gummies to rapid-onset formulations, consider starting with a slightly lower amount until you understand how the faster absorption affects your personal experience.

Mood-Targeted Formulations

We design our products around specific intentions—whether you're seeking creative focus, deep rest, social connection, or pure relaxation.

Each formulation blends hemp-derived THC with functional botanicals and specialty ingredients to create targeted experiences.

Your biology still varies, but these carefully crafted combinations help guide effects toward particular vibes while maintaining the quality and consistency you need for predictable results.

What to Do If It Feels Like Too Much

If you've taken more than intended and are experiencing more intense effects than planned, remember: this will pass.

Understanding the timeline helps—effects typically peak around 3 to 4 hours after consumption and then gradually decrease.

Find a comfortable, quiet space where you feel safe. Stay hydrated with water and consider eating a light snack—some people find that food helps moderate intensity.

Distraction works well: put on a familiar show, listen to calming music, or try to rest.

The Gradual Decline

What feels overwhelming at hour 3 will feel more manageable by hour 5 and mostly resolved by hour 8.

Ride it out in a comfortable environment rather than fighting the experience, which often makes uneasiness worse.

If you're experiencing severe symptoms or anything that genuinely concerns you, seek medical help. Better to err on the side of caution.

Important Disclaimer

We're not a medical or mental health authority, and this is educational content, not medical advice.

If you have questions about how cannabis might affect your specific health situation, consult with a licensed healthcare professional who understands your complete medical history.

How Regular Use Changes What You Feel

When you use cannabis frequently—daily or near-daily, regardless of consumption method—your body adapts to regular THC exposure.

Your system becomes less responsive to THC over time, meaning you need higher amounts for effects comparable to what you experienced when you first started.

If you're a daily smoker or vaper wondering why edibles aren't working, you probably need significantly more than you think.

That 5mg newcomer amount likely won't register at all. Try 20mg to 30mg as your starting point, understanding that even at these higher amounts, your tolerance might shorten overall duration. Regular smokers need different amounts than occasional users.

The Frustrated Daily User

Many regular users find edibles disappointing compared to smoking or vaping—not because edibles are inferior, but because the tolerance they built through daily inhalation applies to edibles too.

Some discover they prefer other consumption methods entirely once they realize how much they'd need to eat for desired effects. Learn more about tolerance and how it affects your experience.

If edibles consistently disappoint despite trying appropriate amounts for your tolerance, consider whether alternative routes—like vaping or flower —might better suit your needs and usage patterns.

Options Without Intoxication

If you want cannabinoid benefits without the high, products rich in CBD or CBG with minimal THC offer another approach entirely. These formulations interact with your endocannabinoid system without producing intoxication, giving you a completely different relationship with cannabis.

Hemp-Derived vs Dispensary THC and Other Practical Questions

Let's clear this up immediately: hemp-derived Delta-9 THC is the exact same molecule as dispensary Delta-9 THC.

The chemical structure is identical, which means identical effects, matching duration, and the same considerations around use.

The difference is legal framework, not chemistry. We produce every product to meet the strict federal standard of less than 0.3% Delta-9 THC by dry weight, as established by the 2018 Farm Bill.

A 15mg gummy weighing 5.5 grams yields about 0.27% concentration—under the legal limit while delivering the same compound found in any dispensary product.

State-Level Variations

Federal legality doesn't guarantee state acceptance. While our products are federally compliant and ship to most states, some states have enacted their own restrictions on hemp-derived THC.

Always verify your local regulations—the legal landscape changes frequently.

Drug Testing Reality

Any product containing Delta-9 THC—regardless of whether it's hemp-derived or from a dispensary—will cause you to fail a standard drug test.

Drug tests detect THC metabolites in your system, and those metabolites are identical regardless of source.

If you have employment screening, legal requirements, or any situation where THC detection would be problematic, avoid all THC products for at least 30 to 90 days before testing.

The "hemp-derived" designation offers no protection in drug testing scenarios.

When Edibles Still Don't Work

If you've tried products from reputable sources at appropriate amounts for your tolerance level and still feel nothing, you might be among the small percentage of people whose genetics make them non-responders to edibles.

Consider sublingual tinctures that bypass liver conversion, or explore alternative consumption methods entirely.

Your Next 5mg With Confidence

You now understand the mechanism behind edible variability: your liver converts THC into 11-hydroxy-THC at a genetically determined rate, creating fundamentally different experiences from identical starting amounts.

You know the timing windows, the variables you can control, and how to systematically find your personal sweet spot.

Here's your concrete next step: Pick a calm evening when you have nothing scheduled for at least 12 hours. Note what and when you've eaten that day.

Start with an amount appropriate for your experience level and tolerance—2.5mg to 5mg if you're new, 10mg to 15mg if you use cannabis occasionally, 20mg to 30mg if you're a daily user.

Find your optimal gummy amount through careful testing.

Working With Your Biology

Track your experience: when you took it, when you first felt effects, when intensity peaked, how long it lasted, and how the overall experience matched your intentions.

After trying the same amount under different conditions a few times, adjust in small increments based on what you've learned.

Look for quality indicators: third-party testing, published Certificates of Analysis, and consistent manufacturing processes.

These remove product variability from the equation, letting you focus on understanding your personal biology rather than guessing whether mislabeling is the problem.

Learn about our quality standards and what sets us apart.

You're not dealing with random chance—you're working with your unique biology. Once you map your personal response pattern, edibles become predictable, controllable, and tailored to exactly the experience you're seeking.